- Home
- Alternatives
- Makeship
Best Makeship Alternative for VTubers & Content Creators
Makeship takes 30-50% of every drop. Your own store keeps 96%+ after Shopify Payments. Same campaign mechanics, but fans become YOUR customers for every future release.
- Keep 96%+ after fees vs 50-70% on Makeship
- Fans in your systems for every future drop
- Any product, any manufacturer, your brand
Why Creators Switch
Keep 70%+ more revenue
vs 30-50% Makeship cut
Own 100% of customer data
Email, retarget, sell again
Any manufacturer, any product
Not limited to plushies
You handle production. Most creators use Alibaba, Budsies, or local manufacturers.
Makeship made plush crowdfunding easy for creators—design a collectible, they handle manufacturing. That convenience is a 30-50% revenue share, not a small fee. On a $20,000 drop, you typically keep $10,000-14,000. Makeship now sells plush, hoodies, vinyl figures, pins, and keychains; campaigns run about 21 days, with production often 2-3 months (up to 90 days).
Fundpop lets you run the same pre-order campaigns on your own Shopify store. You choose the manufacturer and handle fulfillment—and you keep around $19,300 after ~3.5% total fees (from 0.5% Fundpop + Shopify Payments), with every buyer in Shopify and Klaviyo for the next drop. For established creators, the math is obvious.
Last updated:
Why Makeship Users Switch
Common reasons that drive the move to Shopify-based crowdfunding
Revenue Split Kills Your Margins
Makeship takes 30-50% of every sale. That's not a fee—it's a revenue share. On a $50 plush selling 500 units ($25,000), Makeship keeps $7,500-12,500. With Fundpop (~3.5% total including Shopify Payments), you'd keep around $24,125 instead.
Limited to Their Catalog
Makeship now does more than plush—hoodies, vinyl figures, pins, keychains—but you still sell only what they manufacture. Want an art book, a custom enamel set, or a bundle Makeship does not make? On your Shopify store, the campaign can include any product from any manufacturer.
Your Fans Become Their Customers
When fans buy on Makeship, Makeship owns that relationship. You can't email those buyers about your next drop, can't retarget them with ads, can't build a direct relationship. On your store, every buyer joins your customer list forever.
No Control Over Production
Makeship handles manufacturing, which is convenient—but you have no control over quality, timelines, or changes. With your own manufacturer, you can request modifications, rush orders, and maintain the quality standards your fans expect.
No Brand Building
Your Makeship campaign looks like every other Makeship campaign. On your own store, fans experience your brand—your aesthetic, your messaging, your world. That builds loyalty that transcends any single product.
Fixed Production Timeline
Makeship's own docs put manufacturing at about 2-3 months after a successful campaign (up to 90 days), then 7-15 days typical delivery. Working directly with a manufacturer can be faster on repeat orders—or slower on a first sample. You set the schedule, not a catalog queue.
Fundpop vs Makeship
See how the features compare side by side
| Feature | Fundpop | Makeship |
|---|---|---|
| Business model | Fee-based (you manage production) | All-in-one (production included) |
| Your cut after fees | ~96.5% (minus your COGS) | 50-70% (COGS included in their share) |
| Product options | Any product, any manufacturer | Plush, apparel, vinyl, pins (their catalog) |
| Customer data | Instant in Shopify, Klaviyo, pixels | Limited access |
| Brand experience | Your Shopify theme, or custom template | Makeship template |
| Email marketing | Klaviyo, Mailchimp, etc. | No direct access |
| Manufacturing control | Full control | Makeship handles |
| Production timeline | Your manufacturer's schedule | Typically 2-3 months (up to 90 days) |
| Bundle products | Yes, any combination | Limited to Makeship catalog |
| Minimum order | Your MOQ | 200 units typically |
Do the Math: 3 Campaigns, 1 Year
Compare the numbers side by side
Most successful creators run 3-4 merch drops per year. Here's what that looks like over 12 months with a $15,000 average campaign:
Numbers based on 3 campaigns × $15,000 each. Your results depend on campaign size and Makeship's specific revenue share (30-50%).
Why Merchants Choose Fundpop
I installed a couple different crowdfunding apps and this one was the best by far. This app is very simple and uses familiar Shopify UI so it feels like you never leave Shopify. So many useful features such as brand customization, campaign milestones, and the ability to set your campaign goals as number of orders or sales revenue.
Waifu Loot runs each new creator item as a small campaign on its own store: 32 campaigns since August 2026, each with a goal of 10 to 15 units. The Maxine standee reached 66 against a goal of 15.
MRLLING opens each artist collaboration as a pre-order with a goal of 50 units. The Audrey figure with HagenToons reached 199 orders, and the store keeps every buyer as its own customer.
Making the Switch from Makeship
Switching from Makeship means finding your own manufacturer—but that's a one-time setup. Many creators use Alibaba for plush, or work with established merchandise partners. Once you have a manufacturer, install Fundpop, create your campaign, and launch to your audience. The logistics are more work, but keeping ~96.5% after fees instead of 50-70% makes it worthwhile.
Install Fundpop
Add Fundpop from the Shopify App Store. Takes less than 2 minutes.
7-day free trial included.
Create Your Campaign Product
Set up your product with funding goals, timeline, and reward tiers.
Use your existing product photos and descriptions.
Configure Funding Settings
Choose all-or-nothing or flexible funding. Set your goal and deadline.
All-or-nothing creates urgency. Flexible funding reduces risk.
Launch to Your Audience
Share your campaign with your email list, social followers, and community.
The first 48 hours are crucial—plan your launch promotion in advance.
Makeship vs Fundpop FAQ
But Makeship handles manufacturing and fulfillment—isn't that worth the fee?
Finding a plush manufacturer is a one-time effort. Many creators use Alibaba or established merchandise partners. The 30-50% you give Makeship on EVERY campaign adds up fast. On a $20K campaign, that's $6,000-10,000 gone. With your own manufacturer and Fundpop, you keep 96%+ and build a business you control.
How do I find a plush manufacturer?
Many creators use Alibaba suppliers (search "custom plush manufacturer"), work with established merchandise companies like Crowdmade, or use platforms like Printful for smaller runs. Your community likely knows recommendations too.
What about quality control?
You'll need to manage sampling and quality approval yourself—or work with a fulfillment partner who does this. It's more hands-on than Makeship, but you also have more control over the final product.
Can I still do limited-edition drops?
Absolutely. Fundpop supports campaign deadlines and quantity limits. Create scarcity however you want—time-limited, quantity-limited, or both.
Is this only for VTubers?
No—any creator selling merchandise can benefit. YouTubers, Twitch streamers, artists, musicians. Anyone with an audience who's been giving 30-50% to merchandise platforms.
Explore More
Ready to Own Your Crowdfunding?
Join 500+ creators who run campaigns on their own Shopify stores. ~3.5% total fees, full customer ownership.
