Kickstarter vs Indiegogo Complete 2026 Comparison
An honest, data-driven comparison of the two largest crowdfunding platforms. Built from the fee schedules both platforms publish, and from 500+ creators who run campaigns on their own stores.
The Crowdfunding Platform Trade-off
What You Get
What It Costs
Worth the trade-off for a one-off campaign.
Building long-term? Own your audience instead.
Short answer
Pick Kickstarter for a creative project that needs to be found by new backers: it has the larger backer community and publishes its success rate, about 42%. Pick Indiegogo for tech hardware or tabletop games, its focus since Gamefound bought it in July 2025. Fees do not settle it: both take 5% plus about 3% + $0.20 in payment processing, around 8% in total, and both are now all-or-nothing.
Kickstarter and Indiegogo are the two dominant crowdfunding platforms, but they've evolved significantly. Kickstarter remains focused on creative projects with a large, engaged backer community. Indiegogo, now owned by Gamefound since July 2025, has shifted toward tech products and tabletop gaming.
Both platforms charge similar fees (~8% total—see our Kickstarter fees breakdown) and now both offer only all-or-nothing funding. After funding, many Kickstarter creators still need a pledge manager like BackerKit. The choice between Kickstarter and Indiegogo depends on your project type, existing audience, and whether you'd rather run on your own Shopify store instead.
Last updated:
📊 TL;DR Decision Guide
- First campaign, no audience → Kickstarter (for discovery)
- Tech/hardware product → Indiegogo
- Building a long-term business → Your own store with Fundpop (lower fees, own your customers)
Quick Comparison
Kickstarter vs Indiegogo at a glance
| Category | Kickstarter | Indiegogo |
|---|---|---|
| Platform Fee | 5% | 5% |
| Payment Processing | 3% + $0.20 | 3% + $0.20 |
| Total Fees | ~8% | ~8% |
| Funding ModelIndiegogo discontinued flexible funding in Oct 2025 | All-or-nothing | All-or-nothing |
| Success RateKickstarter publishes ~42% (early 2026); Indiegogo does not publish official rates | ~42%Stronger here | ~18-30% (estimated) |
| Audience size | ~25M backersStronger here | ~3M visitors (est.) |
| Backer emails | CSV after campaign ends | CSV after campaign ends |
| Post-CampaignBoth now charge the same 5% + processing on late pledges | Late pledges + Pledge Manager | Late Pledge (was InDemand) |
| Category Strength | Creative, Games, Design | Tech, Hardware, Tabletop |
Building a long-term business?
Your own store with Fundpop: ~50% lower fees, every customer in your Shopify & Klaviyo, and an audience that grows with every campaign. See how it works
Fees & Costs
Kickstarter Fees
- 5% fee on funds raised (successful campaigns only)
- 3% + $0.20 payment processing in the US (Stripe; ~3–5% by country)
- 5% + $0.05 for micro-pledges under $10
- No fee if campaign fails (all-or-nothing)
- Pledge Manager uses the same 5% + processing on later payments
Total: ~8% for typical campaigns
Indiegogo Fees
- 5% fee on funds collected (since the Oct 2025 Gamefound upgrade)
- 3% + $0.20 / €0.20 payment processing (flat, all countries)
- Late Pledge (was InDemand): same 5% + processing
- Tips go 100% to the creator (no Indiegogo tip)
- Pledge manager, Stretch Pay, and VAT tools included
Total: ~8% for campaigns and Late Pledge
Summary: Fees are nearly identical for the live campaign. After the Oct 2025 upgrade, Indiegogo Late Pledge (formerly InDemand) uses the same 5% + 3% + $0.20 as the campaign—not the old 5–15% InDemand stack.
Audience & Discovery
Kickstarter Audience
- ~25 million registered backers
- Strong repeat backer culture
- "Projects We Love" editorial features
- Best for: games, design, film, music, art
- Active community that browses and discovers
Larger, more engaged backer community
Indiegogo Audience
- ~3 million monthly visitors
- Strong in tech and hardware categories
- Now integrated with Gamefound for tabletop
- Paid promotion options (GOGOPicks)
- Less organic discovery than Kickstarter
Smaller audience, stronger in tech/hardware
Summary: Kickstarter has a significantly larger backer community, especially for creative projects. However, most successful campaigns (70-80%) bring their own audience regardless of platform.
Features & Tools
Kickstarter Features (2026)
- Built-in Pledge Manager (launched 2025)
- Pre-Launch Updates emailed to followers
- Pledge Over Time (interest-free installments)
- Secret Rewards and Featured Rewards
- Late pledges for post-campaign orders
- Limited page customization
Indiegogo Features (2026)
- Late Pledge (replaces InDemand) at campaign fee rates
- Built-in pledge manager and stretch goals (Gamefound stack)
- Stretch Pay installments for backers
- 100% of optional tips go to creators
- Adyen payouts for campaigns launched after Oct 2025
- More page customization than Kickstarter
Summary: Both now include a native pledge manager. Kickstarter added Pre-Launch Updates, Secret Rewards, and Pledge Over Time in 2025. Indiegogo runs on Gamefound tech: Late Pledge, Stretch Pay, and stretch goals are included in the 5% fee.
Success Rates
Kickstarter Success
- ~42% overall success rate (Kickstarter Stats, early 2026)
- Comics: ~69% success
- Tabletop games: ~66% success
- Technology: ~24% success
- ~272,000 successfully funded projects; $8.5B+ pledged all-time
Higher success rates, especially for creative projects
Indiegogo Success
- 18-30% estimated success rate
- Official data not published
- 800,000+ campaigns launched
- Previously inflated by flexible funding
- Strong in tech/hardware niches
Lower overall rates, but strong in specific categories
Summary: Kickstarter's higher success rate reflects both their all-or-nothing model (serious creators only) and larger backer community. Your success depends more on your preparation than the platform.
Which Should You Choose?
Recommendations based on your situation
Choose Kickstarter if...
- You're launching a creative project (games, film, music, design)
- You want access to the largest backer community
- This is your first crowdfunding campaign and you need discovery
- You're in a category with high Kickstarter success rates
- You want the "Kickstarter credibility" signal
Choose Indiegogo if...
- You're launching tech or hardware products
- You want to start shipping during the campaign (Express)
- You're in the tabletop gaming space (Gamefound integration)
- You plan significant post-campaign sales via Late Pledge
- You need more page customization options
Build your business on your own store if...
- You're thinking beyond a single campaign
- You want to build real equity in your customer relationships
- You value full control over your brand experience
- Lower fees (~3.5% vs ~8%) matter for your margins
- You want access to your marketing powerhouse (Klaviyo, Meta, 8,000+ Shopify apps)
- You're serious about maximizing customer lifetime value
- You want flexible funding (keep what you raise)
The Third Option: Your Own Shopify Store
More than 500 creators have run campaigns on their own Shopify stores with Fundpop. Here's what we've learned: whether you're launching your first campaign or your tenth, running on your own store gives you lower fees, full control, and the ability to build lasting customer relationships.
- Total fees ~3.5% vs ~8% on platforms
- Real-time Klaviyo integration (no CSV exports)
- Track full funnel—browsers, cart adds, not just pledges
- Use your existing Shopify fulfillment workflow
- Every backer is in your customer list for the next campaign
- Native upsells, bundles, subscriptions in one system
“We had years of successful crowdfunding experience on Indiegogo. We wanted to bring this capability in-house to our own store. The campaign was a massive success!”
Kickstarter vs Indiegogo FAQ
How much would I save running on my own store vs Kickstarter/Indiegogo?
On a $50,000 campaign, platforms take ~$4,000 in fees. On your own Shopify store with Fundpop, you'd pay ~$1,750. That's $2,250 saved — plus you keep the customer relationship for future campaigns.
Which platform has higher fees, Kickstarter or Indiegogo?
Fees are nearly identical: both charge 5% plus ~3% + $0.20 payment processing, totaling about 8%. After the Oct 2025 upgrade, Indiegogo Late Pledge (formerly InDemand) uses that same rate—no longer the old 5–15% InDemand stack.
Does Indiegogo still offer flexible funding?
No. As of October 2025, Indiegogo moved to all-or-nothing funding only, similar to Kickstarter. If you need flexible funding (keep what you raise regardless of goal), you'll need to run your campaign on your own store with a tool like Fundpop.
Which platform is better for board games and tabletop?
Both are strong in tabletop. Kickstarter has the larger backer community and publishes ~66% success for tabletop games. Indiegogo, now owned by Gamefound, shares Gamefound's tabletop tools (stretch goals, Late Pledge, Stretch Pay). Many tabletop creators run on Kickstarter for discovery, then use their own store for expansions.
What happened to Indiegogo in 2025?
Indiegogo was acquired by Gamefound in July 2025 and migrated onto Gamefound technology on October 16, 2025. Flexible funding ended. Fees simplified to 5% + 3% + $0.20. InDemand became Late Pledge at the same rate. New campaigns payout via Adyen; tips go to creators.
Do I need Kickstarter or Indiegogo if I already have an audience?
Not necessarily. Data shows 70-80% of successful campaigns bring their own traffic. If you have an email list or social following, you can run campaigns on your own store with lower fees (~3.5% vs ~8%) and keep all customer data. Platforms are most valuable for discovery when you're starting from zero.
Which platform has better customer support?
Both platforms offer creator support, though response times vary. Kickstarter provides extensive creator resources and guides. Indiegogo offers more hands-on support for larger campaigns. For your own store, you get direct Shopify support plus your crowdfunding app's support.
Can I use both platforms for different campaigns?
Yes, many creators do. A common strategy: use Kickstarter for initial launches (for discovery and credibility), then use your own store for expansions, reprints, and ongoing sales where you already have an audience.
What about BackerKit and other pledge managers?
Many Kickstarter creators still use BackerKit (or Kickstarter Pledge Manager) for surveys, add-ons, and late pledges after funding—another tool on top of ~8% campaign fees. Indiegogo has its own survey tools. On your own Shopify store with Fundpop, orders are native checkouts: see our BackerKit alternative and pledge manager guide.
Learn More
Ready to Try a Different Approach?
Join 500+ creators running campaigns on their own Shopify stores. Lower fees, full data ownership.
